How to Beat

How to Beat Nickel Defense

Five defensive backs on the field. Built to stop the pass. Here is how to run the ball down their throat.

Why Nickel Works

Nickel defense adds a fifth defensive back to the field, replacing a linebacker. This extra defensive back gives the defense better coverage against three and four receiver sets, which are the most common personnel groupings in modern football. The nickel back, usually a slot corner or a hybrid safety, can match up with the slot receiver and take away the underneath routes that spread offenses depend on. Nickel has become the de facto base defense in the NFL and college football because offenses spend the majority of their snaps in 11 personnel.

The coverage benefits are clear. Five defensive backs can play more coverage variations, match up with any receiver combination, and disguise their intentions more effectively than a base defense with only four defensive backs. The tradeoff is size and physicality near the line of scrimmage. The fifth defensive back is typically 20 to 40 pounds lighter than the linebacker he replaced, and that weight difference matters in the run game.

Where It Breaks Down

Nickel puts a smaller, lighter player on the field in place of a linebacker. That player was put on the field to cover, not to stop the run. When the offense runs the ball at the nickel defender, he often cannot hold up against pulling guards, fullback leads, or tight end blocks. The run game becomes the primary weapon against nickel because the defense has voluntarily made itself lighter and less physical in the front seven.

The box count tells the story. Base defense puts seven or eight defenders near the line. Nickel typically puts six. That creates an immediate numbers advantage for the offense in the run game, especially when combined with heavy personnel groupings that add extra blockers. The defense is faced with a choice: stay in nickel and get outmuscled, or sub back to base and risk getting burned in coverage. Offensive coordinators who can force this dilemma control the game.

Schemes That Attack It

Power and gap schemes are the most effective run plays against nickel. Power brings a pulling guard to the point of attack and creates a numbers advantage at the hole. The nickel defender is either forced to take on a pulling lineman, which he cannot do consistently, or give ground and let the running back through. Counter adds misdirection to the power blocking scheme, pulling the play-side defenders one direction while the ball goes the other way. Duo blocking, where two double teams at the point of attack create vertical push, is another excellent choice because the lighter defensive front cannot absorb the extra force.

Personnel is a weapon in itself. Going to 12 personnel with two tight ends on the field forces the defense to either keep the nickel on the field and deal with an extra blocker, or sub back to base and match up a linebacker on a tight end in the passing game. Either way, the offense wins. 13 personnel with three tight ends takes it even further. The heaviest groupings turn the nickel defense into a pass defense that is defending the run, and that is a mismatch every time. In the passing game, target the nickel defender directly. Motion your best receiver to the slot, run crossers and option routes at him, and make him defend in space against your most dynamic playmaker.

Forcing the Dilemma

The best game plans against nickel use tempo and personnel changes to keep the defense guessing. Come out in 12 personnel and run power. If the defense stays in nickel, you have the numbers advantage in the run game. If they sub to base, audible to a passing concept and throw against base coverage with two athletic tight ends running routes against linebackers.

Push the tempo after a heavy run play. The defense wants to substitute to get fresh legs and heavier bodies on the field, but if the offense is already at the line and snapping the ball, the defense is stuck in nickel and the offense runs it again. This strategy of dictating the defensive personnel grouping through tempo and formation is one of the most effective tools in an offensive coordinator's toolkit. Make the defense play on your terms, not theirs.

Run against the light box

Nickel replaces a linebacker with a defensive back. That is one less run defender. Power, inside zone, and gap schemes punish the lighter front.

Go heavy

12 and 13 personnel force the defense to either stay in nickel and get outmuscled or sub back to base and give up a mismatch in the passing game.

Attack the nickel player

The fifth defensive back is often the weakest link. Run at him, motion to his side, and put your best skill player in his zone.

They took out a linebacker. Make them regret it.

Nickel defense is built for the pass. Run the ball, go heavy, and exploit the lighter front.

Build your game plan in Blitz.