Football Analytics
PFF Grades
Pro Football Focus watches every player on every play and assigns a grade. It is the most comprehensive player evaluation system in football, and also the most debated.
How PFF Grading Works
Pro Football Focus employs a team of analysts who watch every snap of every NFL game. Each player on the field receives a grade on every play, ranging from negative 2 to positive 2 in half-point increments. A perfectly executed block gets a positive grade. A missed tackle gets a negative one. These individual play grades are aggregated into an overall season grade that is normalized to a 0 to 100 scale.
The grading process is designed to isolate individual performance from surrounding context. If a quarterback throws a perfect pass that his receiver drops, the quarterback gets a positive grade and the receiver gets a negative one. If a running back gains 80 yards because the offensive line created a massive hole, the linemen get the credit and the back is graded on what he did after the initial blocks. The goal is to separate what each player contributed from the results around him.
Multiple analysts grade the same games, and their grades are cross-checked for consistency. PFF also re-grades plays when coaches film becomes available, since the broadcast angle does not always show everything happening away from the ball. The process is rigorous, but it is still a human evaluation with inherent subjectivity built in.
What the Grades Capture
PFF grades are especially valuable for positions that traditional stats ignore. Offensive linemen do not show up in box scores, but PFF tracks every pass block, every run block, and every penalty. You can look at a guard's pass-blocking grade and see exactly how often he gets beaten, how often he gives up pressure, and how he performs against different types of rushers. No other publicly available system provides this level of detail.
Defensive grades are similarly detailed. A cornerback might not get thrown at often, which means his interception and pass breakup totals will be low. But PFF tracks every snap he plays in coverage, grading his technique, positioning, and ability to stay attached to receivers. A corner who rarely gets targeted because quarterbacks are afraid to throw his way will show up with a strong coverage grade even if his counting stats look quiet.
What the Grades Miss
The biggest limitation of PFF grades is that the graders do not have access to the playbook. When a linebacker drops into a zone and a receiver catches a pass in his area, the grader has to make a judgment call about whether the linebacker was responsible for that zone or whether the coverage had him elsewhere. Sometimes they get it right. Sometimes they do not. This is especially tricky in complex man-match and pattern-match coverages where responsibilities shift based on the route combinations.
PFF grades also struggle with consistency at certain positions. Grading a quarterback is inherently more subjective than grading a defensive end. A pass rusher either beats the blocker or does not. A quarterback's decision-making involves reading the full field, understanding the protection, and making pre-snap adjustments that are invisible to an outside observer. Two graders might disagree on whether a quarterback made the right read, and those disagreements add up over a full season.
Despite these limitations, PFF grades remain one of the best tools available for player evaluation. They are not perfect, but they provide a starting point for conversations that raw stats cannot support. The key is using them as one input alongside film study, traditional stats, and advanced metrics rather than treating them as the final word on a player's performance.
Grade Scale
PFF grades run from 0 to 100. Anything above 90 is elite. 70 to 89 is above average to good. 60 to 69 is average. Below 60 is below average to poor.
Position Grading
Every position is graded differently. Offensive linemen are judged on each pass block and run block. Receivers are graded on route running, catches, and drops.
Grade Limitations
PFF graders do not always know the play call or assignments. Without the playbook, some grades involve educated guesses about who was responsible for what.
Every player. Every play. Graded.
PFF grades give you a way to evaluate the players that box scores completely ignore. Use them wisely and they are one of the best tools in football.