Football Analytics
QBR vs Passer Rating
Two metrics, two very different philosophies. Traditional passer rating has been around since 1973. ESPN's Total QBR launched in 2011 to fix its blind spots. Here is how they compare.
Traditional Passer Rating
The NFL passer rating formula was introduced in 1973 and has not changed since. It uses four components: completion percentage, yards per attempt, touchdowns per attempt, and interceptions per attempt. Each component is scaled, capped, and combined into a single number on a scale from 0 to 158.3. The weird maximum exists because of the way the four sub-calculations are weighted and combined. It was never designed to be intuitive.
Passer rating does a decent job of measuring basic passing efficiency. A quarterback who completes a high percentage of passes, throws for a lot of yards per attempt, scores touchdowns, and avoids interceptions will have a high passer rating. The formula is entirely transparent, and anyone can calculate it from a standard box score. That simplicity is both its strength and its weakness.
The biggest problems with passer rating are the things it ignores. It does not account for sacks, which are partly the quarterback's responsibility. It does not factor in rushing ability. It does not care about game situation, so a meaningless completion in a blowout counts exactly the same as a clutch third-down conversion. And it does not attempt to separate the quarterback's performance from his receivers. A dropped pass and an overthrown pass look the same in the formula.
ESPN's Total QBR
Total QBR was created by ESPN in 2011 to address the shortcomings of passer rating. It uses expected points added as its foundation, which means it accounts for down, distance, field position, and score differential on every play. A 5-yard completion on 3rd and 4 is worth significantly more than a 5-yard completion on 1st and 10, and QBR reflects that difference.
QBR also attempts to divide credit between the quarterback and his supporting cast. If a receiver catches a short pass and breaks three tackles for a 60-yard gain, QBR tries to give the receiver credit for the yards after catch rather than attributing the entire play to the quarterback. It also includes rushing plays and penalizes quarterbacks for sacks when they are responsible for holding the ball too long. The result is a 0 to 100 scale where 50 is average.
The major criticism of QBR is transparency. ESPN has never fully published the formula, which means analysts cannot independently verify the results or understand exactly why one quarterback rates higher than another. There have been individual games where QBR produced results that seemed counterintuitive, and without access to the full methodology, it is impossible to explain why. The metric has improved significantly since its launch, but the black-box nature remains a sticking point for many in the analytics community.
Which One Should You Use?
For a quick, transparent snapshot of passing efficiency, passer rating still works. It is easy to calculate, widely understood, and available for every quarterback going back decades. If you want to compare quarterbacks across eras or just need a fast reference point, passer rating gets the job done. Just remember what it leaves out.
For a more complete picture of quarterback performance in a given season or game, QBR is the better tool. It captures rushing, accounts for situation, and attempts to isolate the quarterback's contribution from the players around him. The lack of transparency is a real downside, but the underlying methodology is sound. Most serious analysts use EPA-based metrics directly rather than relying on either QBR or passer rating, but QBR is a solid single-number summary if you want one.
QBR Formula
ESPN's proprietary metric uses EPA, divides credit between quarterback and receivers, adjusts for situation, and scales to 0 to 100. The formula is not fully public.
Passer Rating Formula
Based on completion percentage, yards per attempt, touchdown rate, and interception rate. The formula is public and has been used since 1973. Scale runs from 0 to 158.3.
Head-to-Head Comparison
QBR accounts for rushing, sacks, and situation. Passer rating only measures passing on a per-attempt basis. QBR is more complete but less transparent.
Not all quarterback metrics are equal.
Passer rating is simple and transparent. QBR is comprehensive but opaque. The best analysis uses both alongside film and EPA.