Football Analytics
Success Rate
A straightforward, powerful measure of offensive efficiency. Success rate asks one question on every play: did the offense stay on schedule? The answer reveals more than yards per play ever could.
What Counts as a Successful Play?
Success rate defines a "successful" play based on what the offense needs to stay on schedule for a first down. On first down, gaining at least 50 percent of the yards to go is a success. So a 5-yard gain on 1st and 10 qualifies. On second down, the threshold rises to 70 percent of the remaining distance. On third and fourth down, only a first down or touchdown counts as a success. These thresholds are based on the idea that an offense needs to make steady progress toward the first-down marker on early downs to avoid facing difficult third-down situations.
The specific thresholds can vary slightly depending on the analyst, but the general framework is consistent across the analytics community. Some models use 40 percent on first down and 60 percent on second down. Others stick with the 50/70 split. The differences are minor because the core insight is the same: not all yards are equal, and staying ahead of the chains is the most important thing an offense can do on a play-by-play basis.
Why Success Rate Beats Yards per Play
Yards per play is one of the most commonly cited offensive statistics, and it is deeply misleading. A team that averages 5.5 yards per play sounds efficient. But what if that average comes from a bunch of 2-yard runs and the occasional 50-yard pass? The offense is actually failing on most of its plays and getting bailed out by explosives. Success rate exposes this pattern because it measures how often the offense does its job, not just the average result.
Consider two offenses that both average 5.0 yards per play across a game. One gains 5 yards on every single play. The other alternates between 0-yard plays and 10-yard plays. The first offense has a 100 percent success rate on first down. The second has a 50 percent success rate. In practice, the first offense is far more likely to sustain drives, control the clock, and score consistently. Yards per play cannot tell the difference. Success rate can.
Success rate also correlates more strongly with winning than yards per play does. Teams that stay on schedule and consistently face manageable third-down distances tend to win more games than teams that rely on big plays to compensate for inefficient early downs. The best offenses in football combine a high success rate with a healthy explosive play rate, but if you had to choose one, success rate is the better predictor of sustained offensive production.
Using Success Rate in Analysis
Success rate becomes even more powerful when you split it by situation. Run success rate versus pass success rate tells you whether a team's ground game is actually helping the offense or just burning downs. Many teams run the ball on first down out of habit, and their run success rate on first down is terrible. They would be better off passing more on early downs, and success rate makes that case clearly.
You can also split success rate by personnel grouping, formation, or quarter. A team might have a strong overall success rate but struggle badly in 12 personnel, suggesting that particular package is not working. Or a team might have a much higher success rate in the first half than the second half, which could indicate fatigue, predictability, or problems with halftime adjustments. These splits are where success rate goes from a useful number to a genuinely actionable tool.
On defense, success rate allowed is one of the cleanest measures of defensive performance. A defense that limits opposing offenses to low success rates is consistently putting them in bad down-and-distance situations. Even if the yardage totals look average, a defense with a low success rate allowed is doing its job by making the offense work harder on every drive. Pair success rate allowed with EPA per play allowed, and you have a very clear picture of defensive efficiency.
By Down
On first down, gaining 50 percent of the yards to go counts as a success. On second down, 70 percent. On third and fourth down, only a first down or touchdown qualifies.
Run vs Pass
Success rate can be split by run and pass to reveal scheme efficiency. A team might have a high passing success rate but a low rushing success rate, indicating a run game that is hurting the offense.
Explosive Plays
Success rate measures consistency. Explosive play rate measures big-play ability. The best offenses rank highly in both, staying on schedule while also hitting home runs.
Stay on schedule. Win more games.
Success rate measures the one thing that matters most on every snap: did the offense keep the chains moving? Consistent offenses win.